Follow me:
Listen on:

3 Reasons Why Marketing Sourced Pipeline Should NOT Be a KPI (And What You Should Do Instead)

In the constant battle for marketers to prove their worth to their Executive overlords, there has been an adoption of one key metric to show that marketing is having an impact.

And that metric is marketing sourced pipeline.

I’ve seen it as a key KPI in organisations both large and small. And I’m going to give you three reasons why you should think twice before using it as a KPI for marketers, and three alternatives to start reporting on.

But before I do that, let’s define marketing sourced pipeline to make sure we’re all on the same page.

Definitions: What Is Marketing Sourced Pipeline?

Marketing sourced pipeline is pipeline (i.e. leads) that have been generated by marketing efforts, and then handed off to the sales team for further nurturing and qualification.

Basically, if that lead was generated by a marketing effort as the first point of contact, then that lead would be determined ‘marketing sourced’.

Think: collecting emails at events, running lead generation activity with webinars and ebooks, capturing the details of someone who comes to your website through Google Ads.

Anything that enters your CRM that marketing can go: “Hey! That was from our marketing stuff” – that’s marketing sourced.

3 Reasons I Don’t Like Marketing Sourced Pipeline

As a marketer, I don’t really like reporting on marketing sourced pipeline as a key KPI for 3 main reasons:

  1. It encourages marketers to focus on ‘lead gen’ to the detriment of the business
  2. It puts marketing and sales at odds with each other
  3. It doesn’t acknowledge the complex reality of the B2B buying journey

Reason 1: Marketing Sourced Pipeline Encourages A Focus On Lead Generation

Marketers that are measured on marketing sourced pipeline are often encouraged and rewarded for bringing in as many ‘leads’ as possible. Afterall – we want to show that marketing is filling up the pipeline with leads that we sourced!

So here’s what happens: we marketers try and source as many emails and contact details as we can, collecting them through gated content like ebooks and webinars, or emails collected at events.

That means we optimise all of our activities and budgets to collecting leads. And the focus becomes quantity over quality.

Let me show you why this focus on quantity over quality becomes a problem. Check out this diagram below, showing the journey from Lead to Customer.

What often happens when marketing is measured on ‘marketing sourced pipeline’: a very inefficient way of acquiring new customers that is not sustainable.

Sure there’s a few steps missing, like the point at which the lead becomes a MQL (Marketing Qualified Lead) and then SQL (Sales Qualified Lead), but it illustrates an important point. Despite starting with 500 leads generated by marketing, only 1% converted to an opportunity. And of those opportunities, 20% became customers – resulting in 1 new customer.

This is a grossly inefficient process for acquiring new customers, and unfortunately isn’t unusual when marketing teams are incentivised to generate as many leads as possible. What this diagram doesn’t show is the manual labour associated with the sales team calling to qualify these leads and turn them into opportunities. This is a huge expense for the business that can be overlooked as an expense related to marketing, particularly in earlier stage businesses.

When the business finally evaluates how profitable the entire acquisition process is (from lead to customer), taking into account sales’ time to service marketing’s leads, they see that it’s not hitting their CAC target (cost per acquisition). This then results in one of two scenarios:

  • Scenario 1: they respond by asking marketing to increase the number of leads, and lower the cost of acquiring the leads (CPL)
  • Scenario 2: they tell marketing that they need to start generating better leads

I’ve lived out both scenarios personally, and let me tell you – neither are fun.

That means we optimise all of our activities and budgets to collecting leads. And the focus becomes quantity over quality.

Increasing lead volume and reducing the CPL in a short space of time is not only extremely difficult without a significant increase in brand power, but it still won’t solve the problem of sales having to waste their time on these junk leads.

Asking marketing to produce better leads requires stakeholder management. Because – yes – we can optimise for better leads, but the result is there will be fewer of them. That means less leads for sales to call, and possibly some sales staff out of a job. This is a difficult conversation to have, and a tough situation to manage as stakeholders and sales staff freak out when lead numbers start dropping.

And this is all the result of a business measuring marketing based on how many marketing sourced leads they bring in.

Reason 2: Marketing Sourced Pipeline Makes Sales & Marketing Fight

Alignment of marketing and sales is the holy grail. But measuring marketers on marketing sourced pipeline isn’t going to help us find it.

When marketers are optimised to send stacks of leads to sales, the focus on quantity over quality often results in frustration as sales are forced to find the needle in the haystack. Cold calling people who don’t want to speak to you for hours on end isn’t a great feeling when you’re heavily incentivised by commission.

It also creates opposition between marketing and sales. For example, let’s say the biggest customer last year entered your CRM by downloading an ebook. That’s marketing sourced.

But when sales called them, they didn’t even remember downloading the ebook, let alone know who your company is or what it does. Over the course of 6 months, before they became a customer they were courted with outreach from sales, and consumed the helpful content created by marketing. Finally when budget, timing and the business case is right – sales get them across the line as a customer.

The CRM says that marketing was responsible for getting this customer. I’m not so sure sales would agree.

Reason 3: Buying Journeys Are Complex

Buying journeys are complex. We wish the journey was as simple as:

Customer downloads ebook —> Sales speaks to customer —> Sales wins customer

But it’s not. It looks a bit more like this:

Source: Gartner on The B2B Buying Journey

The buyer needs a lot of education, needs to wrangle a bunch of different stakeholders, and has to care about the problem enough to work towards a solution. But when we optimise for marketing sourced pipeline, marketing can effectively say their job is done at the point where a prospect downloads our ebook and we get their contact details.

Rather, there should be continuous education from marketing past that point that enables the buyer to self-educate, until they are ready to talk to sales. Even while talking to sales, marketing still needs to be doing the legwork to support sales and stay top of mind, to show the match between the product and their pain points.

Marketing should also be thinking beyond the sale, continuing to help expand, upsell, and cross-sell to existing accounts.

Marketing sourced pipeline as a KPI just doesn’t encourage marketers to do that.

The One Exception: Website Sourced Pipeline

There is one measurement of pipeline I don’t mind. That’s high-intent, website sourced pipeline. This is pipeline from prospects who fill out a high-intent form on your website, like a ‘Request A Demo’ form. However I only think it’s fair to measure this when the product less complex and is of relatively low value (< $15,000). The rationale behind this is that marketing should be able to do all of the education without sales, and get a prospect to request a demo.

However when the product is complex and higher value, naturally there’ll need to be some more 1:1 involvement between your business and the prospect – and that’s normally where sales comes in.

So How Should We Measure Our Marketers?

One alternative to marketing sourced pipeline adopted by more mature marketing teams is marketing influenced pipeline.

Rather than looking at where the pipeline originated from (e.g. sales or marketing), it looks at whether marketing ‘touched’ the prospect (e.g. consuming content, attending events etc.), to help usher them through the pipeline.

This has its own host of issues, but at least recognises the complexity of B2B Marketing and that marketing and sales need to work together as one revenue team.

A Framework To Measure B2B Marketing Performance

I suggest that B2B Marketers should adopt a 3 tiered reporting framework that:

  • Demonstrates marketing is having a positive impact on the business
  • At minimum is aligned with sales and is buildinging trust and affinity with those in your ICP (Ideal Customer Profile)

These are the 3 tiers:

  • Tier 1: Website sourced pipeline and revenue
  • Tier 2: Qualitative and quantitative insights indicating business results
    • Tier 3: Channel level KPIs indicating you’re making an impact with your ICP in your target segments

    I will detail these in a future article. But I normally suggest B2B marketers start with Tier 3, and as they make inroads eventually report on Tiers 2 and 1.

    For now, if your marketing function is being judged based on the marketing sourced pipeline it’s bringing in, please evaluate if it’s having any of the negative effects discussed in this article.

    And stay tuned for Episode 72 of The B2B Playbook podcast where we go through each of the 3 Tiers of reporting in detail!

    Strategy, Templates & Tools To Drive More Revenue With Marketing

    Our 5 BEs Framework teaches b2b marketers exactly how to drive more revenue with your marketing.

    We share our Framework step-by-step every week on The B2B Playbook.


    There’s 3 ways you can learn and implement it in your own business:

    1. Listen to The B2B Playbook Podcast
    2. Subscribe to our Newsletter
    3. Apply for The B2B Incubator

    (P.S. The B2B Incubator gives you strategy, templates and tools you need to implement this in your business over 12 weeks. Click here to find out more or apply now).


    Subscribe & Get The Best Of The B2B Playbook Delivered To Your Inbox

    Join other B2B Marketers and Owners and get the latest B2B marketing strategy, tips and tricks delivered to your inbox.

    What Marketers Like You Are Saying...

    Sam Henderson
    Sam Henderson
    Skalata Ventures | Head of Marketing
    Read More
    Love the podcast and the way you 'waterfall' content from it (and the genuineness that comes through)!
    Mike Carr
    Mike Carr
    LIN3S | Digital Strategy & Paid Search
    Read More
    Just wanted to reach out to let you know how much I’m enjoying the podcast - I definitely get the feeling that I’ve learned something I can use after each episode
    Carter Wright
    Carter Wright
    RevOps Research Collective | RevOps Researcher
    Read More
    Been following for a bit and trying to catch up on the podcast. You post some great content and the podcast is 🔥
    Previous
    Next
    Chris Kondou
    Chris Kondou
    KanDo Consult | Founder
    Read More
    Starting and growing a business isn't easy no matter how good your service or offering is. Doing digital marketing feels like climbing Everest. Thankfully the B2B playbook podcast breaks it all down for you. George & Kevin are great to listen to & step you through the 5Be's of how to get your marketing right. After a few listens you can start climbing that mountain to your marketing success.
    Jacob Olsen
    Jacob Olsen
    PicUp | Co-Founder // Head of Operations
    Read More
    Enjoying all your content and listening to the B2B podcast episodes. Always get some value from them 👌
    Catherine Lethbridge
    Catherine Lethbridge
    RAA | Innovation Consultant
    Read More
    George and Kevin are a wealth of knowledge in B2B marketing. They passionately share their knowledge in their B2B Playbook podcast and each episode brings on new insights. I recommend it to any new marketers starting in the B2B space: it's like having your own marketing mentors on the go!
    Previous
    Next
    Charlene Wasson
    Charlene Wasson
    Diospatial | Marketing Manager
    Read More
    I have been following some of your content on LinkedIn and started listening to your podcast. I really like the stuff you guys are putting out there.
    David Wippel
    David Wippel
    TRIGO | Managing Director
    Read More
    Hey George, Just want to tell you how much I enjoy your content (podcast, posts on LinkedIn,...) As a web dev with no prior marketing know how who is now CEO of a small agency with marketing responsibility there is so much to learn. Your work is a great source. Love it
    Jessica Tyrrell
    Jessica Tyrrell
    AusPayNet | Marketing & Comms Coordinator
    Read More
    Really do love the work you guys do and appreciate how you make B2B marketing more accessible ❤
    Chris Kondou
    Chris Kondou
    KanDo Consult | Founder
    Read More
    Starting and growing a business isn't easy no matter how good your service or offering is. Doing digital marketing feels like climbing Everest. Thankfully the B2B playbook podcast breaks it all down for you. George & Kevin are great to listen to & step you through the 5Be's of how to get your marketing right. After a few listens you can start climbing that mountain to your marketing success.
    Beixi SUN
    Beixi SUN
    Woolworths at Work | Marketing Executive
    Read More
    The main reason I love the podcast is I can get to know the B2B marketing mindset & experience. There’s tons of blogs/ courses online to talk about B2B marketing on strategies, tools, and models...but I found not many deliver the message of mindset to the audience. The mindset and experience are something you gained and tested from day-to-day work, and not easy to be googled.
    Liam MacCormack
    Liam MacCormack
    HWPO Marketing | Head of Growth
    Read More
    Honestly, I really like your podcast format. The breakdown and analysis angle of different companies B2B strategies mixed with your own framework and some tactical approaches is a B2B podcast mix that I haven’t stumbled upon other than yours and I really enjoy it. DG does mostly interview, Chris Walker has his Demand Gen approach, Metadata talks about what they do internally. And I enjoy all of them. But you two have figured out an interesting mix that brings something new and that’s not easy. You’ve got a routine listener here!
    Monica Moran
    Monica Moran
    Edstart | Marketing Manager
    Read More
    Come 5am every Monday morning when I do my daily run, I tune into The B2B Playbook podcast. George and Kevin are excellent at distilling the many complex aspects of B2B marketing. And more importantly, giving away very practical advice on how to create a sound marketing strategy and execute it on a tactical level. As a bonus, George is a genuinely helpful, all around nice guy. He practices what he preaches. On LinkedIn you can see George doesn't just talk the talk - he does what he advises his audience should do. And shows how his playbook works for his business. It's true people! - Helpful marketing content leads to inbound opportunities that turn into revenue!
    Ben Andrews
    Ben Andrews
    Titomic | Marketing Manager
    Read More
    The B2B playbook is just that - a practical guide to B2B marketing, providing endless tips, tricks, and insights. It's really practical. Particularly how to get experts to write for you. I'm in a pretty niche industry with tricky applications, so that helped a lot. Awesome stuff! Please keep it coming!
    Mercedes Carrin
    Mercedes Carrin
    Medianet | Head of Marketing
    Read More
    Your podcast is such a great resource for us - wanting to make the change to Demand Gen, keep it up 🙂
    Lee-Roy Chitambira
    Lee-Roy Chitambira
    AlayaCare | Marketing Coordinator
    Read More
    I am really enjoying your podcast and learning so much so big thank you
    Sanjay Shah
    Sanjay Shah
    Visionary Digital Studios | Director
    Read More
    Love the podcast George - plenty of epic wisdom, making massive impact - very much appreciated!
    Fernanda Bispo
    Fernanda Bispo
    Nexon Asia Pacific | Marketing Programs Manager
    Read More
    Hi George I love your podcast, very interesting and easy to listen to!
    Drew Brucker
    Drew Brucker
    LASSO | VP of Growth
    Read More
    Marketing podcasts are everywhere. And there’s nothing worse than ear candy that you can’t clearly apply. But the B2B Playbook brings a unique and timely perspective that’s especially actionable.
    Anusha Kannan
    Anusha Kannan
    Suffolk in the Hub | Assistant Account Director
    Read More
    I have been listening to the B2B Playbook since George and Kevin launched it. The podcast episodes have such rich practical knowledge and they took one step further and created the B2B incubator. B2B incubator looks promising especially because they do not say “learn this, and you will be a millionaire overnight” it has a concrete strategy, how to learn from your mistakes, and the nitty-gritty of being a B2B marketer. Listen to their podcasts and also be a part of this program as I am sure like their podcasts their strategy is doable and will yield results. Remember, you have to implement what you learn from them!
    Michelle J Raymond
    Michelle J Raymond
    Good Trading Co | Global LinkedIn Pages Expert
    Read More
    I don't listen to podcasts, but I do make the exception for yours if I'm driving. It is so well thought out, researched, and logical and adds a tonne of value. I'm very confident your B2B Incubator would be the same.
    Nishant Choudhary
    Nishant Choudhary
    Codewave Technologies | Growth Marketing Manager
    Read More
    I was listening to your podcast. It's amazing. The 5 BEs framework, the way you diagnose educational content strategy... 💥🚀

    I'm George, and I'm an embarrassingly passionate B2B marketer.

    But it wasn't always that way. When I first got into B2B marketing, I actually found it so confusing. There was conflicting advice - and I kept pursuing the promise of "the one thing" that would work - with varying success.

    With my own agency and working in-house, I tested different strategies and tactics to see:
    (a) which ones could be done by a small marketing team
    (b) which ones actually resulted in REVENUE for the business

    We then turned the stuff that works into one cohesive strategy that I follow when I consult with B2B clients.

    It's called our 5 BEs Framework.

    And now we're dedicated to sharing it, right here, on The B2B Playbook.

    We're giving away our 5 BEs Framework step-by-step, and creating the resource I wish I had when I first fell in love with B2B marketing.

    When I say step-by-step - I mean it! Start the podcast at Episode 1, and work your way through.

    If that sounds like too much, we give you the strategy, templates & tools in our 12 week program - The B2B Incubator.

    Check it out here: https://theb2bincubator.com/

    I'm also extremely active and share much of our framework on LinkedIn - so please feel free to connect with me there and say hi!

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/b2b-marketing-expert/

    Join the discussion

    Further reading

    Subscribe